Glass Or Tinnie Options

[hustler57]

hey fellow boaters,

was chatting to a mate this morning who asked me what do i prefer a fiberglass boat or a tinnie boat,

i told him it all depends on what size boat he wants and what car he would use to tow the boat and what type of fishing we would do,

what does every 1 else think ?

[Spudly]

Primarily Fishing, I think Plate alloy is hard to beat if going offshore etc, Can handle a bit more knocking around and your not so worried about niose etc..

If its a fishing / Family boat i think glass offers a comfortable ride

If my name was poly id say......

If your just looking for a river fishing boat its hard to go past a small, light tinny..

[hustler57]

yeah but ive got a glass boat now and before this boat i had a 15 foot tinnie, i found the tinnie to be to bumpy as where the glass i feel rides the swell better and softer, i guess with a tinnie u can pull up at the ramp and not be as worried about pulling up on the ramp or any hidden underwater rocks as with the glass boat im always carefull

[poly]

well my name is poly and i am going to have a say in this one, if u are considering a new boat then polycraft should be on your checklist for these reasons 1 they are tougher than a prest tinney's ride as well as a glass boat and the plastic they are made from is very buoyant, the color will not fade or need to be repainted at any time, it is very easy to work on them with wood tools
now that i have owned one for 3 years i could not see myself going back to a glass or alloy boat

[Spudly]

Poly, i did mean to add...

If your looking for a river/bay boat then they are definatly an option..

[SUMOFISHIN]

I have opted for aluminium, although the ride is harder they are a lot easier to handle, I haven't had the experience of a large alloy! but I would have been confident to go to NZ Land in my 19ft Glass boat, I think that if you was to hit a large sharp object it would tear any material they were made from dependant upon speed of course. I think GRP boats will be around a while yet.

[Jumpus GooDarus]

Well I've both types over the years even had a poly as well see hear

http://www.fishing-oz-style.info/forum/ind...hp?showtopic=51

These days I have a couple of goats both alloy but 2 completely different boats & I'm not refering to size either I honestly could never see myself going back to a glass boat unless of course it's perpose was 2B a lardy Dah Boat.

Alloy boats are built for one specific purpose in mind

A Fishing Platform

How the boat rides well that's determined by material used deadrise etc I'd like to see how many glass boats can handle a sea as well as my big tinny or should I say Plate Boat

[hustler57]

it also depends on how much money $$$$ the person who is looking at buying a boat hs got as well, i havnt been in a new alloy as of yet, but i have been in a near new glass boat and thought it was great, not every 1 in this world can afford a new or near new boat so i guess one would have to look at what they can get in the price range of what they can spend and then compare the pair,

and i agree with poly regarding the poly's, i havnt heard any bad reports regarding them as of yet,

quote

Jumpus GooDarus Posted Today, 07:04 PM

How the boat rides well that's determined by material used deadrise etc I'd like to see how many glass boats can handle a sea as well as my big tinny or should I say Plate Boat

have u tested a glass boat which has got the same specs are ur plate boat has got jg ?

[Spudly]

How about rubber!! hey hey!??

[Jumpus GooDarus]

Well the boat I had prior to my Plate Boat was a 23 ft Carrabean did a fair bit of work on it B4 starting to fish out of it it originally had an inboard which I didn't want so I beefed up the transom & built a pod for the 2 new 140 HP Evenrudes [ What a load of crap they were]

So yes the specs were pretty similar prior to the carabean I had a 18ft tinny well the carrabean was luxuary compared to the tinny but bear in mind I had to do alot of glassing on the carrabean like most glass boats gunnels way to high cut them down.

When I got my plate boat found it was awesome perfect gunnel hight self draining etc etc & you're correct a good plate boat costs more but dont forget they also retain there value alot better than a glass boat thats why back then I bought the carrabean cause I couldn't afford a plate boat.

My honest opinion ? reckon my Plate boat out performed the carrabean in all aspecs if there's one thing I have to say about the plate boat I ALWAYS FEEL SAFE IN IT & that rides high in my books

[hustler57]

so are you saying that for fishing a plate boat is the best option remembering if you have got enought $$$$ to spend on a plate boat,

because like many other people i use my boat for more then just fishing, during the summer i often take 5 or 6 friends out with us for a cruise on the harbour or the bays,

i also do a lot of water skiing and wwake boarding and tubeing,

i guess it all comes down to trying to find that perfect boat (which doesnt exist) for everything that you want it for, unless of course you have plenty of $$$$ to buy a few boats for each water sport

[Jumpus GooDarus]

No such thing as a perfect boat which can do everything cause everyone uses their boats differently for example years ago when I had the 18ft tinny I could fish alot more places than when I had the bigger boats.

I was going to do a trip around Oz 3 years back & thats why I got the little 4.8 meter tinny got crook & didn't go, I was going to sell it last year motor had only done 30 hrs but started fart arsing about with SP's & fishing rivers Pt Hacking, Towra & all those places I cant get into with the big boat & tell you what I was enjoying so I decided to keep the little tinny as well

[hustler57]

yep thats what im saying , you cant get the perfect 1 boat for all of your water needs, unless you have big $$$ to buy ya self the perfect boat for out side and another for inside ect ect......

but ya gotta gotta remember that a hell of a lot of fishos also have families and when the boat isnt being used for fishing its prob being used for towing the kids on a tube or something like that

[Spudly]

exactly right jumpas. cannot find the perfect boat!!

If i had the money, I would buy a cruise craft explorer 625, that would be my ultimate boat..

However I cant, and I like hustler want to ski/board behind my boat, so I need at least 90hp, but i also want to be able to take it offshore, Not 10 miles but be able to get out there on a satisfactory day and get home if it did turn to crap..

So Im not yet sure where to go.. Something in a cuddy cabin, around the 5.5m with a 130hp would suit me well.

[Fed]

I've heard corrosion for whatever reason can be a big problem in alloy boats.
Glass boats always seem more user friendly, softer, smoother, quieter, warmer.
If I was buying a new boat I'd buy what I have now but with a slightly larger motor.

[Jumpus GooDarus]

Alloy boats only cop corrosion because of a bad fit out & neglect no different to glass boats copping osmosis

About the only thing I agree with you on Fed is power

And not because I'm a rev head either the bigger the motor/'s means you dont have to work it/them as hard but the power is there when you want it.

I had a guy checking out my bigger goat which has a pair of 115's on the back he's just ordered a new plate boat from stessel slightly bigger than mine but a centre consol [waste of a hull in my books] but just goes to show the logic of some people.

Anyway he's already got the motor yes a single & it's a yammy 115 hp 2 stroke apparantly he got it @ a good price well I laughed @ him told him the motor would struggle getting the boat up not to mention how slow it would be & this guy intends to fish places likes Browns as well.

Even gave him some figures what my boat did with the twin 85 hp 2 strokes & what it can do with just one of the 115's running but guess that info fell on deaf ears, his reply was it's only a centre consol & dosen't have the weight of a hardtop on it

I gave up talking to him dont like talking to iriots esp after I tried explaining weight is only a small factor & the main obstacle is the hull dragging through the water

[poly]

So I'm not yet sure where to go.. Something in a cuddy cabin, around the 5.5m with a 130hp would suit me well.

RUM this may sound like an ad for poly but i would not right them off your list, they build a top 5.3 cudy put a 115 on the back and have all the fun u want it will give u the performance of glass and the toughness of alloy, the 625 will come in time as that is the boat u would truly love and i don't blame u for that
we have a gr8 sight where u can go to get info on poly's the members there will give u all the help u could ever need and they will be honest with u

so come along members let,s help RUM find the best boat in the intermediate range we can, i have had my say so come no have a go but u must be under $33.000 for B M T

[Spudly]

is that the price for th poly 5.3?? Thats bloody good....

[Spudly]

Ill take this one

[poly]

the last time i checked it was $32.000 from a dealer down hear that was about 12 months ago